Paintball Suppressors
Printed From: Tippmann Paintball
Category: News And Views
Forum Name: Thoughts and Opinions
Forum Description: Got something you need to say?
URL: http://www.tippmannsports.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=155906
Printed Date: 30 April 2026 at 6:24am Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Paintball Suppressors
Posted By: UV Halo
Subject: Paintball Suppressors
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:03pm
Yeah, this post will sure draw a lot of attention.
It seems people on this board really hate the words "Silencers" and "Suppressors", and go on and on about how illegal they are.
The construction of one these days revolve around fitting a shroud to a
ported barrel. This concept has drawn a lot of hostility from
people who claim that even posting such information is related to
illegal activity.
That being said, how do all of you feel about Smart Parts Stealth
Barrel kit? How is it that a ported barrel with a shroud is
illegal but, yet, SP is going the distance in making sure people know
about their new stealth barrel kit?
Do you think it's jsut a matter of time until the ATF comes along and
shuts them down, or is all the hoopla about about paintball silencers
(ported barrel w/shroud design to be specific) jsut a bunch of hype?
Don't know what I'm talking about? Click http://www.warpig.com/paintball/technical/paintguns/smartparts/sp8/stealth_rails/ - here .
Keep this discussion civil please.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Replies:
Posted By: Snake6
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:13pm
The ATF has shut down companies before(the last one was in the early 90's I believe) for manufacturing paintball silencers. It is illegal, but as long as there is no discussion on how to make them, or talk of making them you won't get a strike.
-------------
|
Posted By: Hairball!!!
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:44pm
|
It's not a silencer. It's just a super-ported barrel in a shroud that does nothing for sound muffling.
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:53pm
Actually, in the late 80s and early 90s, companies that were making
paintball silencers were not making a ported barrel/shroud
design. They were making the type that attach to the end of a
paintball barrel. I used to own one back then (before
discussion about their legality came about). The ATF did not shut
them down, they were advised by the ATF, that if they continued to make
them, they could face charges. Bowing to the pressure, they
stopped. This is understandable since this design was fabricated
as a complete silencer.
Bill Mills approached the ATF about this and they advised him that they
could be affixed to a firearm and result in sound suppression,
therefore they were illegal. Bill even went back to them with a
design based on a ported barrel with a shroud, and they again said that
this combo could be affixed to a firearm barrel and work.
Therefore, they too were illegal.
There is one thing about the ATF that a lot of people seem to forget
(I'm not pointing this out for you Snake6 but for anybody else who may
not be too aware of this). They are a part of the Executive
branch of government. The Legislative branch made the laws about
silencers. The ATF, under the Executive Branch, is responsible
for enforcing them (enforcement means bringing the accused to
court). The Judicial Branch, is responsible for deciding who is
guilty (and who is not), and delivering justice.
Now, Smart Parts is a decent sized company, they probably have worked
with local, state, and federal governments at one point or another on a
variety of issues. I would even be willing to bet that they
have lawyers in their service (on a contractual basis, if not fully
employed by Smart Parts). That being said, do you think they
would unknowingly or, willingly open themselves up to being found
guilty of making and selling firearm silencers, where the charges are
fairly substantial?
Time will tell but, I'm betting on the fact that Smart Parts has a
pretty sound case for what they are doing (a ported barrel with a
shroud design).
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: the_blade
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:54pm
once agian its just an item marketed to new players to think they have a "sniper barrel"
------------- 95 base neon 3.0 cai, knifedged crankshaft 60 mill throttle body,14 crane cam crane springs/retainers eagle rods port matched/ polished intake p&p head shaved .015 phantom grip diff dohc exuast
|
Posted By: You Wont See Me
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 7:57pm
Smart parts definatly has lawyers. Theres no questioning that.
------------- A-5
E-Grip
JCS Dual Trigger
DOP X-CORE 8 stage x-chamber
Lapco Bigshot 14" Beadblasted
Optional setup:
R/T
Dead on Blade trigger
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:01pm
Hairball!!! wrote:
It's not a silencer. It's just a super-ported barrel
in a shroud that does nothing for sound muffling. |
You need to read two things. The link I posted above and, the following:
A. §921(a)(24)
The terms "firearm silencer" and "firearm muffler" mean any
device for silencing, muffling, or diminishing the report of a portable firearm,
including any combination of parts, designed or redesigned, and intended for use
in assembling or fabricating a firearm silencer or firearm muffler, and any part
intended only for use in such assembly or fabrication.
Numerous paintball
silencers tested by the Firearms Technology Branch have been determined to be,
by nature of their design and function, firearm silencers as defined in 18 U.S.C.,
Section 921(a)(24). An individual wishing to manufacturer a firearm silencer must
receive prior approval from ATF by submitting an ATF Form 1 and paying a $200
making tax.
the_blade wrote:
once agian its just an item marketed to new players to think they have a "sniper barrel"
|
Nope, no reference at all to snipers. But, since you make the
reference, silencers get bigger application in other warfare
disciplines since in firearms silencers measurably effect long range
accuracy. They are obviously pushing this as a quieter barrel,
with no promises of long range accuracy.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: bravecoward
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:08pm
|
It's fake, it's made for people(noobs) who think it's real.
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:10pm
bravecoward wrote:
It's fake, it's made for people(noobs) who think it's real.
|
Read the link. A 2dB reduction is at least a 25% reduction in sound.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: Snake6
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:20pm
UV Halo wrote:
the_blade wrote:
once agian its just an item marketed to new players to think they have a "sniper barrel"
|
Nope, no reference at all to snipers. But, since you make the
reference, silencers get bigger application in other warfare
disciplines since in firearms silencers measurably effect long range
accuracy. They are obviously pushing this as a quieter barrel,
with no promises of long range accuracy.
|
Actually it is not the Silencer that effects the accuracy or the round, it is the powder charge itself that does. A silencer on standard rifle ammunition some of the sound, but it cannot eliminate the distictive "Crack" as the round goes super sonic. Therefore Subsonic Ammunition was developed to eliminate this distinctive noise. However because Subsonic ammo does not have the muzzle velocity of supersonic rounds, you lsacrifice accuracry and range.
-------------
|
Posted By: Hairball!!!
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:34pm
UV Halo wrote:
Hairball!!! wrote:
It's not a silencer. It's just a super-ported barrel
in a shroud that does nothing for sound muffling. |
You need to read two things. The link I posted above and, the following:
A. §921(a)(24)
The terms "firearm silencer" and "firearm muffler" mean any
device for <span style="font-weight: bold;">silencing, muffling, or diminishing the report</span> of a portable firearm,
including any combination of parts, designed or redesigned, and intended for use
in assembling or fabricating a firearm silencer or firearm muffler, and any part
intended only for use in such assembly or fabrication.
|
Paintball companies have been selling barrels with porting for years, so how is it illegal? There's nothing different about the new SP barrel.
|
Posted By: You Wont See Me
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:37pm
Because porting can't be modified for use on firearms.
I would think it'd be the shroud that would make it illegal (if it was,
the more i look at it and read about it the less i think it is).
------------- A-5
E-Grip
JCS Dual Trigger
DOP X-CORE 8 stage x-chamber
Lapco Bigshot 14" Beadblasted
Optional setup:
R/T
Dead on Blade trigger
|
Posted By: Snake6
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:56pm
I would tell you exactly how firearms silencers work, but I am not delving into that on the forum. If you understand how real silencers work, it is easy to uderstand what are considered illegal paintball silencers.
-------------
|
Posted By: Hitman
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 8:59pm
As Hairball said, It's just a barrel with holes drilled in it. No differen't than any other barrel...
------------- [IMG]http://img527.imageshack.us/img527/4874/stellatn8.jpg">
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 9:23pm
Hitman wrote:
As Hairball said, It's just a barrel with holes drilled in it. No differen't than any other barrel...
|
Read the link I posted. The Stealth Barrel Kit is a Ported Barrel with a shroud.
To be sure you're clear on what the ATF has to say about ported Barrels with a shroud, follow this http://www.corin.com/bill/paintball/silencer.html - link.
Please people, read the full post and ask questions if you're not clear
about what is being said. Don't just assume you know what is
being said.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 9:25pm
Snake6 wrote:
UV Halo wrote:
the_blade wrote:
once agian its just an item marketed to new players to think they have a "sniper barrel"
|
Nope, no reference at all to snipers. But, since you make the
reference, silencers get bigger application in other warfare
disciplines since in firearms silencers measurably effect long range
accuracy. They are obviously pushing this as a quieter barrel,
with no promises of long range accuracy.
|
Actually
it is not the Silencer that effects the accuracy or the round, it is
the powder charge itself that does. A silencer on standard rifle
ammunition some of the sound, but it cannot eliminate the distictive
"Crack" as the round goes super sonic. Therefore Subsonic Ammunition
was developed to eliminate this distinctive noise. However because
Subsonic ammo does not have the muzzle velocity of supersonic rounds,
you lsacrifice accuracry and range.
|
We are in agreement Snake6, I made a misrepresentation, and thanks for
not going into how silencers are made on this topic. It's clearly
not the point.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: stratoaxe
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 10:07pm
|
Gun silencers are really easy to make...
But aren't paintball guns quiet enough anyway?
Maybe I'm not understanding it.
-------------
|
Posted By: Apotheosis
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 11:03pm
|
Yes, in compairson to a firearm, but they are still quite loud. Espically when one is trying to be a "sniper".
|
Posted By: Squishey
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 11:21pm
the sp8 stealth says the same bs as the a-5 stealth. i acutally found the a-5 stealth to be louder then a normal a-5. they should of called it the a-5 hammer or something like that. btw paintball silencers ARE legal in canada i've looked into it a bit. and they are also legal as long as the don't silence a real firearm more then 5 decibells i think it is.
------------- Canadians do it on top.
|
Posted By: ridesnowbrdr
Date Posted: 08 June 2006 at 11:53pm
wrong forum.
-------------
|
Posted By: Mack
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 4:34am
Okay, I read the posted link and this is what I see:
- The barrel/shroud combination is unquestionably designed to quiet the report of the marker. "Quieter operation was one of the design goals for the Stealth Barrel and
how it got its name."
- The design is probably legal for the following reasons
- The additional length probably has as much to do with the sound
reduction as anything else. (Longer barrels use more air to get the
ball out, thus utilizing the excess air pressure that is responsible
for the report of the marker.)
- The porting can not be taken off of the barrel and put on a real firearm.
- The shroud is the only part where the legality of this system
can be legitimately questioned, but the following should be considered.
- It is unlikely that the shroud, designed specifically for this marker, could be installed on a real firearm.
- If it was installed on a real firearm, it could not possibly
provide a silencing benefit unless the firearm barrel was ported* to
release expanding gasses from firing into the shroud.
- If a real firearm barrel was ported in such a manner, it is
unlikely that the plastic shroud (if of similar quality to the standard
ones I've examined) would survive the experience of firing.
- Finally, the very description offered in the article brings
into question if the shroud can actually help quiet the marker at all.
Remember that porting quiets the report of a regular marker by allowing
excess gas to escape gradually as the ball travels down the barrel as
opposed to exiting the end of the barrel suddenly and expanding with a
loud pop. Now consider the following statement: "The interior support walls of the Stealth
Barrel foregrip are of a smaller diameter than those of the short foregrip,
and the Stealth Barrel has a smooth polished outer finish, rather than
bead-blasted, so that it can fit snugly into the foregrip. The fit
is so tight, in an effort to prevent air – and sound – from passing between
the chambers, that the Stealth Barrel ships from the factory lubricated
with grease to make installation and removal easier."
It sounds as if the tight fit of the shroud would defeat the purpose of
the porting. (If the air can't escape the chambers, the back pressure
would prevent the ports from operating at full efficiency and you would
still have excess air coming out the end of the barrel.) If I would
have to guess, based on the information
provided, I would say that this barrel is probably quieter due mostly
to it's extra length.
*Homemade porting on a real firearm barrel would very likely ruin the
barrel and could be dangerous. (It sounds like an activity engaged in
by future Darwin Award winners.)
-------------
|
Posted By: Belt #2
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 5:02am
|
Edited:
My purpose-less post was uneeded, Kaybeck owned this one.
|
Posted By: Kayback
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 8:37am
Snake6 wrote:
Actually it is not the Silencer that effects the accuracy or the round, it is the powder charge itself that does. A silencer on standard rifle ammunition some of the sound, but it cannot eliminate the distictive "Crack" as the round goes super sonic. Therefore Subsonic Ammunition was developed to eliminate this distinctive noise. However because Subsonic ammo does not have the muzzle velocity of supersonic rounds, you lsacrifice accuracry and range. |
Thats only partially right. Supressors can and do affect the accuracy of a rifle, even a pistol.
For example the Mk23 fires standard 230 grain FMJ ammo, which is sub sonic with or whithout the supressor. It uses one load.
By putting the supressor on the pistol it changes the POI by 2 inches at 25 yards.
A properly designed supressor on a real rifle can improve the accuracy of the rifle.
Quite a lot of the "random" inaccuracies a rifle suffers from is when the bullet exits the barrel, the rapidly expanding propellant gasses move past it and unsettle it a bit. Competition guns all have crowned muzzles to even out this turbulance. A supressor can have the same effect, literally allowing the bullet to escape into "clear" air before the propellant gasses catch up.
Because you eliminate some of the random inaccuracies, you are left with more predictable flight paths and I've seen groups tighten up when a PROPERLY DESIGNED supressor was attached to a rifle.
There are also other things that detract from the accruacy, or at least the expected accuracy. The added weight of a basic screw on supressor can affect the flexibility of a barrel, it can affect the straightness of a barrel, it can to 101 other things that can detract from a rifles accuracy.
You are right is saying that the super sonic crack can give away the fact a rifle has been fired, however the report that's left on most firearms will still be louder than that.
Te idea of supressing a long ranged weapon is simply to disguise the location of the shooter. The fact a shot has been fired will still be obvious when the target keels over dead. It's to make the source of the shot hard to distinguish. As the sonic boom of the bullet is generated AT THE BULLET, this is only audible after the bullet has passed, and is impossible to use to "source" the shot.
For closer in work supressors are used for a couple of reasons. 1) is it's damn noisy to shoot a long arm inside a building. Ths supressor moderates this sound down to less dangerous levels. 2) it helps with IFF. If you can hear gunfire, you know it isn't a friendly. 3) they also work as all round flash supressors and this helps with night ops. There is also the added benifit of making it harder to hear when people are shooting in your area.
For paintball, supressors are NOT ILLEGAL. They are REGULATED. All you need is to apply to the BATFE for a $200 tax stamp to own the specific item, and you can own it and use it on your paintball gun.
IIRC you also need a certain tax stamp to produce the supressors, which is what most of the companies who made them lacked.
KBK
|
Posted By: Justice
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 9:04am
ridesnowbrdr wrote:
wrong forum. |
way to contribute Moe Moe!
Why would you need a "silencer" on say a DM5. Heck I can barely hear them shoot standing next to it at the chrono.
-------------
-JUSTICE
http://www.myspace.com/outkastpaintball - Outkast Myspace
|
Posted By: Snake6
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 12:59pm
Kayback,
I was trying to dumb it down a little bit, therefore i lft alot of stuff out that didn't really need to be said. There was never really any need for this whole discussion in this thread anyways. I proboblly should have never started down this path of discussion, because we are detarcting from the topic.
-------------
|
Posted By: rednekk98
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 2:11pm
|
Nice to see Kayback posting again.
Anyways, for the guy on the last page, the A-5 stealth isn't advertised as being any quieter. The "stealth" line of markers are geared towards sniper wannabees, so they used a catchy phrase. They aren't saying the gun is any quiter, since a flatline is usually louder than a normal barrel.
Again, if silencers are legal in your area, for the proper tax stamp you can own one. Most things are legal if you have enough money.
Supressors on rifles, or anything with supersonic ammo do hide the source of the shot well. In a few weeks you're going to experiance rounds going over your head while you're pulling targets in the pits, you'll understand how your hear the noise coming from the bullet itself and it's not really traceable.
|
Posted By: Enos Shenk
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 3:36pm
Its not that people dont like the term silencer, its just that Tippmann has instructed the moderators to keep discussion of illegal or dangerous activity off the forum.
I wont lock this because its more discussion than anything else, but if this delves into the realm of "Heres how I built my paintball silencer" it will get the lock treatment.
-------------
|
Posted By: rednekk98
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 3:40pm
|
on another interesting note, porting to quiet firearms is apparently legal, sinc cabela's sells a 5' long ported extention for a 12ga for use with subsonic ammo for waterfowl hunting in urban areas.
|
Posted By: Apotheosis
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 4:20pm
|
I made my own supressor for my A-5 by cutting the stock barrel down to three inches. The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it.
|
Posted By: 636andy636.
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 4:24pm
Apotheosis wrote:
I made my own supressor for my A-5 by cutting the stock barrel down to three inches. The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it.
|
     LOL Smrt post right there
------------- [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v291/anthonymartinez/402cdjo-1.gif">
|
Posted By: Dazed
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 4:59pm
UV Halo wrote:
bravecoward wrote:
It's fake, it's made for people(noobs) who think it's real.
|
Read the link. A 2dB reduction is at least a 25% reduction in sound.
|
Decibels are how sound is measured. Two decibels off of 54 is nowhere near 25%. At least, not using the math I was tought in school.
|
Posted By: UV Halo
Date Posted: 09 June 2006 at 6:20pm
Here are my comments on other people's posts:
Squishey wrote:
the sp8 stealth says the same bs as the a-5 stealth. i
acutally found the a-5 stealth to be louder then a normal a-5. they
should of called it the a-5 hammer or something like that. btw
paintball silencers ARE legal in canada i've looked into it a bit. and
they are also legal as long as the don't silence a real firearm more
then 5 decibells i think it is.
|
This isn't about regular ported
barrels. The Stealth Barrel Kit for the SP8 has a proven (tested
in the review I linked) reduction in noise over the stock barrel.
I think everyone here is in agreement that yes, a regular ported barrel
will reduce the report of a paintball gun. But, the ATF isn't
concerned about just plain ported barrels (I don't know why but, I
suspect that they don't do anything for a firearm). Sorry,l I
didn't clarify in my post- I don't know what the laws are in Canada,
this post is U.S. centric.
ridesnowbrdr wrote:
wrong forum. |
Look dude, if you got nothing more
to say than one or two ignorant words to add to a thread, Why
bother? I've told you this before. This post is in the
right forum because this is "Thoughts and Opinions" and I wanted
peoples Thoughts and Opinions (albeit informed) about how it is SP is
able to make a barrel like this in light of the ATF's stance on ported
paintball barrels with shrouds.
Mack wrote:
Okay, I read the posted link and this is what I see:
- The barrel/shroud combination is unquestionably designed to quiet the report of the marker. "Quieter operation was one of the design goals for the Stealth Barrel and
how it got its name."
- The design is probably legal for the following reasons
- The additional length probably has as much to do with the sound
reduction as anything else. (Longer barrels use more air to get the
ball out, thus utilizing the excess air pressure that is responsible
for the report of the marker.)
You are misinformed here.
Added Barrel length is an additional amount of friction, which requires
more gas for the ball to leave the barrel at the same speed (assuming
that the paintball/bore match is the same). It is the porting at
the very least which is responsible for noise reduction.
- The porting can not be taken off of the barrel and put on a real firearm.
Read my reply to Squishy, above.
- The shroud is the only part where the legality of this system
can be legitimately questioned, but the following should be considered.
- It is unlikely that the shroud, designed specifically for this marker, could be installed on a real firearm.
- If it was installed on a real firearm, it could not possibly
provide a silencing benefit unless the firearm barrel was ported* to
release expanding gasses from firing into the shroud.
- If a real firearm barrel was ported in such a manner, it is
unlikely that the plastic shroud (if of similar quality to the standard
ones I've examined) would survive the experience of firing.
Read this http://www.corin.com/bill/paintball/silencer.html - link to
understand why the ATF is concerned. Further, the ATF doesn't
care if a silencer only survives one shot (hint: find out what happened
to the "potatoe silencer" and "2-liter bottle silencer" guys.
- Finally, the very description offered in the article brings
into question if the shroud can actually help quiet the marker at all.
Remember that porting quiets the report of a regular marker by allowing
excess gas to escape gradually as the ball travels down the barrel as
opposed to exiting the end of the barrel suddenly and expanding with a
loud pop. Now consider the following statement: "The interior support walls of the Stealth
Barrel foregrip are of a smaller diameter than those of the short foregrip,
and the Stealth Barrel has a smooth polished outer finish, rather than
bead-blasted, so that it can fit snugly into the foregrip. The fit
is so tight, in an effort to prevent air – and sound – from passing between
the chambers, that the Stealth Barrel ships from the factory lubricated
with grease to make installation and removal easier."
It sounds as if the tight fit of the shroud would defeat the purpose of
the porting. (If the air can't escape the chambers, the back pressure
would prevent the ports from operating at full efficiency and you would
still have excess air coming out the end of the barrel.) If I would
have to guess, based on the information
provided, I would say that this barrel is probably quieter due mostly
to it's extra length.
Again, you are mis-informed about how Silencers work. So yes, I give this http://people.howstuffworks.com/question112.htm - link (Moderators, I'm not discussing how to make one).
*Homemade porting on a real firearm barrel would very likely ruin the
barrel and could be dangerous. (It sounds like an activity engaged in
by future Darwin Award winners.)
|
I agree with you here. But again, not the point of this thread.
Kayback wrote:
For paintball, supressors are NOT ILLEGAL. They are
REGULATED. All you need is to apply to the BATFE for a $200 tax stamp
to own the specific item, and you can own it and use it on your
paintball gun.
IIRC you also need a certain tax stamp to produce the supressors, which is what most of the companies who made them lacked.
KBK
|
Let me rephrase, Silencers are a
controlled device under the NFA. Having one without a license
(even for paintball, according to the ATF) is illegal. They call
it a "Making Tax" and any transfer of ownership must be applied
for. i.e. Specops PB can make you one. In doing so, they
pay the ATF to make it, and you apply for ownership (through local, and
federal government law enforcement offices), and when Specops transfers
the device to you, they charge you for the "Making Tax".
Dazed wrote:
[QUOTE=UV Halo]
Decibels are how sound is measured. Two decibels off of 54 is
nowhere near 25%. At least, not using the math I was tought in
school. |
My bad, I evaluated what a 2DB
difference is on the lower portion of the scale. That being said, what does your
math say about the difference between 54, and 52? In any case, I wish
Warpig did a comparison to another ported barrel.
------------- M98C- W/QwkStrpCut
Comp Air & Palmer Fatty Stab
Gas-Thru Stock
Lapco Sight Rail W/ADCO 30MM EDOT
Qloader W/ CMS
Freak SS W/Stif-Tip * Flatline * Armson Stealth
|
Posted By: Kayback
Date Posted: 10 June 2006 at 5:08pm
UV Halo wrote:
Kayback wrote:
For paintball, supressors are NOT ILLEGAL. They are
REGULATED. All you need is to apply to the BATFE for a $200 tax stamp
to own the specific item, and you can own it and use it on your
paintball gun.
IIRC you also need a certain tax stamp to produce the supressors, which is what most of the companies who made them lacked.
KBK
|
<span style="color: rgb(0, 0, 255);">Let me rephrase, Silencers are a
controlled device under the NFA. Having one without a license
(even for paintball, according to the ATF) is illegal. They call
it a "Making Tax" and any transfer of ownership must be applied
for. i.e. Specops PB can make you one. In doing so, they
pay the ATF to make it, and you apply for ownership (through local, and
federal government law enforcement offices), and when Specops transfers
the device to you, they charge you for the "Making Tax".</span>
|
Which is what I was trying to say :) Thanks.
Snake6, yeah, I was just trying to say that supressors don't necicarily detract from a weapons accuracy, they can enhance it, and sub sonic isn't required for effective supression if your goal isn't 100% silence.
Rednekk98, good to see the oldies still around, still dispensing their knowledge. Just finished a most wicked IDPA shoot, 1/2 in daylight, 1/2 in darkness. Around 6 hours of solid shooting :) Really need to get back ont he reloading press, I shot out basically all my .45ACP and all my 9x19mm.
So far, in this country, supressors for firearms are legal as anything. I can get one for my Glock or my 1911 as easily as one for my rifle. I've tried my hand at making some for my paintball gun, but because I lack any machineing skills it was all done from plastic. And while they worked, they were never 100% in line with the bore, so lead to numerous barrel breaks.
Apotheosis
The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it. |
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not. Sorry if my joke meter is out of whack, but it's not the ball's friction that makes the sound, it's the higher than atmospheric pressure propelant gas exiting the barrel that creates a pressure wave that your ear interprets as noise.
Cutting a barrel will INCREASE the report of a paintball gun.
You could, if you were a better mathematician than I am, build a "silencer" for your paintball marker by INCREASING the length of your barrel. How farI have no idea, but you'd need to drop the propellant gas down to the same as the atmoshphere, where ever you are playing.
As I said I've no idea how long this barrel would have to be, but you don't need any porting, or shrouds, or anything. Just a hell long piece of barrel :p
Rednekk98, You sure about thatbarrel porting on a shotgun reduces the report? I suppose it can, there will be less of a pressure differential at the muzzle. But I've fired proted and compensated handguns before, and for the shooter at least, there is a marked increase in report....
KBK
|
Posted By: Apotheosis
Date Posted: 10 June 2006 at 9:10pm
Kayback wrote:
Apotheosis
The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it. |
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not. Sorry if my joke meter is out of whack, but it's not the ball's friction that makes the sound, it's the higher than atmospheric pressure propelant gas exiting the barrel that creates a pressure wave that your ear interprets as noise.
Cutting a barrel will INCREASE the report of a paintball gun.
You could, if you were a better mathematician than I am, build a "silencer" for your paintball marker by INCREASING the length of your barrel. How farI have no idea, but you'd need to drop the propellant gas down to the same as the atmoshphere, where ever you are playing.
As I said I've no idea how long this barrel would have to be, but you don't need any porting, or shrouds, or anything. Just a hell long piece of barrel :p
KBK |
Jesus, it was a joke. I knew it would make it louder and wanted some "sniper" to try it. I figured it would be rather funny, him trying to be all stealthy and what not sneaking through the woods only for his gun to be super loud.
|
Posted By: Kayback
Date Posted: 11 June 2006 at 10:05am
Like I said, I couldn't tell if you were being sarcastic or not. It was 3 am when I posted that reply, and I'd been awake 22 hours already.
I probably wouldn't have heard the sarcasm if you'd put a warning flag infront of it.
KBK
|
Posted By: sort
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 9:56am
|
Apotheosis wrote:
Kayback wrote:
Apotheosis
The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it. |
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not. Sorry if my joke meter is out of whack, but it's not the ball's friction that makes the sound, it's the higher than atmospheric pressure propelant gas exiting the barrel that creates a pressure wave that your ear interprets as noise.
Cutting a barrel will INCREASE the report of a paintball gun.
You could, if you were a better mathematician than I am, build a "silencer" for your paintball marker by INCREASING the length of your barrel. How farI have no idea, but you'd need to drop the propellant gas down to the same as the atmoshphere, where ever you are playing.
As I said I've no idea how long this barrel would have to be, but you don't need any porting, or shrouds, or anything. Just a hell long piece of barrel :p
KBK |
Jesus, it was a joke. I knew it would make it louder and wanted some "sniper" to try it. I figured it would be rather funny, him trying to be all stealthy and what not sneaking through the woods only for his gun to be super loud.
|
Too bad the smart ones know better-- >:-)
------------- Revelations 6:8--It's not revenge, it's Punishment.
|
Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 10:44am
Dazed wrote:
UV Halo wrote:
bravecoward wrote:
It's fake, it's made for people(noobs) who think it's real.
|
Read the link. A 2dB reduction is at least a 25% reduction in sound.
|
Decibels are how sound is measured. Two decibels off of 54 is nowhere near 25%. At least, not using the math I was tought in school. |
The decibel rating is exponential. I believe it's 10x amplification of sound for every 3 decibels.
-------------
|
Posted By: Snake6
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 10:46am
Why did you bump this super old thread?
-------------
|
Posted By: GI JOES SON
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 11:57am
|
i just realized when snake posted how old this thread is....why would you bump it?
and why do paintball guns even need silencers? who cares how quiet the marker is?
|
Posted By: Jack Carver
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 12:28pm
|
I knew something was wrong when "wrong forum" didn't come up till the very end of the 1st page, and there was no TKD or Choopie ridiculing people....
|
Posted By: Heres To You
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 12:30pm
25%?
That's not a silencer, it's a make-me-a-little-less-louder.
No offense, but where I play, where not shooting a half mile away where that 25% would even be effective. All of our "kills" are usually within such a range that 25% wouldn't make any difference between a stock barrel.
I realize your trying to bring out the benefits of the barrel, but it's just not practical, unless your just into that type of thing.
------------- "War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse."
|
Posted By: carl_the_sniper
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 3:45pm
sort wrote:
Apotheosis wrote:
Kayback wrote:
Apotheosis
The friction of the ball scraping up against the barrel is what makes the loud sound in the first place, so by cutting the barrel down 5 inches I eliminated 5/8ths of the sound. Try it. |
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not. Sorry if my joke meter is out of whack, but it's not the ball's friction that makes the sound, it's the higher than atmospheric pressure propelant gas exiting the barrel that creates a pressure wave that your ear interprets as noise.
Cutting a barrel will INCREASE the report of a paintball gun.
You could, if you were a better mathematician than I am, build a "silencer" for your paintball marker by INCREASING the length of your barrel. How farI have no idea, but you'd need to drop the propellant gas down to the same as the atmoshphere, where ever you are playing.
As I said I've no idea how long this barrel would have to be, but you don't need any porting, or shrouds, or anything. Just a hell long piece of barrel :p
KBK |
Jesus, it was a joke. I knew it would make it louder and wanted some "sniper" to try it. I figured it would be rather funny, him trying to be all stealthy and what not sneaking through the woods only for his gun to be super loud.
|
Too bad the smart ones know better-- >:-) | symbol of death!
------------- <just say no to unnecessarily sexualized sigs>
|
Posted By: ANARCHY_SCOUT
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 7:56pm
No.
------------- Gamertag: Kataklysm999
|
Posted By: Squishey
Date Posted: 21 January 2007 at 8:45pm
UV Halo wrote:
Yeah, this post will sure draw a lot of attention.
It seems people on this board really hate the words "Silencers" and "Suppressors", and go on and on about how illegal they are.
The construction of one these days revolve around fitting a shroud to a
ported barrel. This concept has drawn a lot of hostility from
people who claim that even posting such information is related to
illegal activity.
That being said, how do all of you feel about Smart Parts Stealth
Barrel kit? How is it that a ported barrel with a shroud is
illegal but, yet, SP is going the distance in making sure people know
about their new stealth barrel kit?
Do you think it's jsut a matter of time until the ATF comes along and
shuts them down, or is all the hoopla about about paintball silencers
(ported barrel w/shroud design to be specific) jsut a bunch of hype?
Don't know what I'm talking about? Click http://www.warpig.com/paintball/technical/paintguns/smartparts/sp8/stealth_rails/ - here .
Keep this discussion civil please.
| have you ever heard or shot an sp-8 with the "suppressor barrel" for it? it does not silence the gun at all, i find it just as loud as the shorter stock sp-8 barrel.
------------- Canadians do it on top.
|
Posted By: Kayback
Date Posted: 22 January 2007 at 5:00pm
Holy crap. I can't believe this topic got resurected.
Jeezes.
And the Decibel scale isn't what's used to measure the energy of sound, it's the Bel scale.
This is why the deciBel is such a screwed up system. It's measurements that are 1/10 of a Bel. Each increase in Bel represents a 10 times increase in power.
KBK
|
Posted By: Bolt3
Date Posted: 22 January 2007 at 5:14pm
Paintball sucks.
------------- <Removed sig for violation of Clause 4 of the New Sig Rules>
|
Posted By: sort
Date Posted: 02 February 2007 at 1:30pm
|
Squishey wrote:
UV Halo wrote:
Yeah, this post will sure draw a lot of attention.
It seems people on this board really hate the words "Silencers" and "Suppressors", and go on and on about how illegal they are.
The construction of one these days revolve around fitting a shroud to a ported barrel. This concept has drawn a lot of hostility from people who claim that even posting such information is related to illegal activity.
That being said, how do all of you feel about Smart Parts Stealth Barrel kit? How is it that a ported barrel with a shroud is illegal but, yet, SP is going the distance in making sure people know about their new stealth barrel kit?
Do you think it's jsut a matter of time until the ATF comes along and shuts them down, or is all the hoopla about about paintball silencers (ported barrel w/shroud design to be specific) jsut a bunch of hype?
Don't know what I'm talking about? Click http://www.warpig.com/paintball/technical/paintguns/smartparts/sp8/stealth_rails/ - here .
Keep this discussion civil please.
| have you ever heard or shot an sp-8 with the "suppressor barrel" for it? it does not silence the gun at all, i find it just as loud as the shorter stock sp-8 barrel.
|
But that's just it....it's not ALL THAT LOUD....after listening to the reports of an A-5 sounding off, for example, the SP-8 is a whisper in comparison....yes, it still makes noise, just somewhat subdued.....it works for me.....so unless folks around here wanna send SmartParts a mass e-mail campaign, tell 'em that they're full of beans, and have them put the cards on the table and show tangible proof of said silencer/supressor capabilities, I say "Who Cares??!!??"
I just wanna play.
------------- Revelations 6:8--It's not revenge, it's Punishment.
|
Posted By: jerseypaint
Date Posted: 02 February 2007 at 1:43pm
|