Print Page | Close Window

Preference on HPA or CO2

Printed From: Tippmann Paintball
Category: Paintball Equipment
Forum Name: Upgrades and Customizing
Forum Description: Trick it out!
URL: http://www.tippmannsports.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=169237
Printed Date: 02 February 2026 at 4:08am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Preference on HPA or CO2
Posted By: uno187
Subject: Preference on HPA or CO2
Date Posted: 06 August 2007 at 9:43pm
I recently upgraded (so I thought) to a HPA tank from CO2.  I was told by a few comrades to do the switch so I did.  I have had nothing but trouble with my HPA tank and trying to tune my marker to it.  To boot I have never had problems running CO2.

I am wondering how players feel about each system and which they prefer and why.




-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit



Replies:
Posted By: mod98commando
Date Posted: 06 August 2007 at 11:00pm
What kind of problems are you having? I have never had an issue related to the use of HPA as opposed to CO2. I largely prefer HPA because pressure is more consistent, the pressure gauge let's you know how much air is left so you don't have to keep track of how much you shoot or wait for the gun to fart, fills are quick and easy, I get more shots per fill from my 88/4500 than a 20oz could give me, HPA is affected much less by the weather, and liquid CO2 is not an issue. CO2 will let you shoot the gun but it tends to freeze things up, bust o-rings, and you won't get many shots out of a fill if it's cold out unless you have an x-chamber or something. However, if I had to use CO2, my anti-siphoned 16oz hooked up to my stabilizer is a pretty good backup. Between the anti-siphon tube and the reg, the gun doesn't freeze up and the pressure is actually pretty consistent for CO2. I still prefer my HPA tank though.

If you're still having problems with your HPA setup, let us know what the problem is and I'm sure somebody can help you fix it. There should be no modifications necessary to switch from CO2 to HPA.


-------------
oreomann33: Everybody invades Poland

Rofl_Mao: And everyone eats turkey

Me: But only if they're hungary

Mack: Yeah but hungary people go russian through their food and end up with greece on everyth


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 06 August 2007 at 11:12pm
To start my gun would not shoot above 250fps until I got the reg rebuilt and now the 1800psi bursting disk keeps blowing so I have to take it in again. 

The problems I am having are more related to the tanks themselves and maybe its just my bad luck with them.  I guess I need some good pros to stick it through and get my tank working.  Then the other tank I had went in for Hydro where the reg broke off in the tank rendering it useless.

So I bought another tank with more problems it seems.  I have never had a problem with any of the 7 CO2 tanks I own.  So it is a little discouraging to spend ruffly now and when I buy a new reg to replace the on that was broke will be over $300.  By now I could have bought 2 new tanks for that price.

I just need to I it worth it to stay with HPA and get through these problems.



-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: Bruce A. Frank
Date Posted: 06 August 2007 at 11:48pm

I have had no problems with Crossfire tanks or their regulators. Who did your hydro? They certainly were not stopped from doing the test and did remove the broken part remaining in the bottle neck, didn't they?

I like Crossfire so well that I have installed their valve/regulator on all three of my tanks. If you had no spiking problems and no freeze up problems then there was probably no good reason to switch to HPA.



-------------


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 07 August 2007 at 7:42am
The first tank that broke was not a crossfire and I had to drill it out myself. The second tank I bought to replace has been giving me problems too.

It's just discouraging when you switch and have nothing but problems and wonder if it is worth it in the long run.

I'll get over this bump but for more than it should have cost me. Tough lesson learned. Next time I will ask you guys questions before I jump right into something and get hosed


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: RoboCop
Date Posted: 07 August 2007 at 10:44am
Did you buy a new or used tank? If people take care of them, they should be ok getting used. The problem with your burst disk going off is most likely that the spring stack in the reg is not functioning properly. I had the same problem. I wouldn't have bought a HPA tank that needs a rehydro. Atleast find something with a couple of years.


Posted By: sinisterNorth
Date Posted: 07 August 2007 at 11:49am
I still use CO2 on my pumps, but I've never had a problem when I've used pre-owned tanks at the field.

-------------
Pumpker'd; (V.) When a pump player runs up and shoots you at point blank range because you thought 20bps made you good.


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 07 August 2007 at 6:37pm
Yeah the Hydro thing was a lesson.  I talked to some local shops about doing the hydro and it was cheap so as I thought I got a good deal on the tank and then no big deal getting the hydro done. Wrong. Thats where I did not do enough research and/or ask the questions on this forum.

So I got hosed and wasted alot of money trying to get to where I thought I wanted to be. But o well I'm getting wiser.


Do most fields rent out HPA tanks?


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: Bruce A. Frank
Date Posted: 08 August 2007 at 1:43am

Originally posted by uno187 uno187 wrote:



Do most fields rent out HPA tanks?

The field I play is switching all their rental markers to HPA (mostly Tippmann 98Cs). When I have had a tank malfunction, they have taken my tank for security and given me an HPA tank for the day (I did pay for the refills.)



-------------


Posted By: RoboCop
Date Posted: 08 August 2007 at 1:46am
Most fields will have HPA tanks for rent. Sure they will be small 45/3000 steel tanks, but they work.


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 08 August 2007 at 7:49am
Yes the key words there are they work. Small is ok just to get through the day.

I will fix what I got and the next time my tank goes down I'll look to rent one then.

Hopefully Crossfire can fix my problem today. Nice they are only an hour away from me.


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: diedonimpact
Date Posted: 08 August 2007 at 9:08pm
if you are having trouble with your HPA system bring in your HPA AND your gun to a shop. they should be able to point u in the right direction

-------------


Posted By: Skillet42565
Date Posted: 08 August 2007 at 9:24pm
My tank is currently 3 years out of hydro and no troubles.  NitroDuck pwns.

-------------


Posted By: Bruce A. Frank
Date Posted: 09 August 2007 at 1:46am

Originally posted by Skillet42565 Skillet42565 wrote:

My tank is currently 3 years out of hydro and no troubles.  NitroDuck pwns.

Well, my field will check to see that your tank is still under test. I do like my 90/4500 Nitro Duck...mainly because it was cheap 'cause no one wanted a tank that large. Got it with 3 years left on the test for $85. I then spent another $65 on it to install the Crossfire valve (converted from cradle mount)



-------------


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 09 August 2007 at 10:56am
Let me run this by you guys a minute.  Got this tank online due for hydro (my mistake I know now) took it to a local paintball shop for hydro. They called me the next day and said there had been a problem with the tank. They broke the reg off inside the tank. So now its useless. They tell me that whoever had it apart before put too much locktite on it when they put it back together and they couldn't do anything for me on another tank. So I take the tank and broke reg and leave. I proceed to remove the broke half from the bottle messing up the threads a bit. Then I take it to crossfire to see if the can fix it. They can't and condemn the tank for "Exposure to fire and damaged threads". Now I know that the guy who broke the reg in the first place charred the neck and in turn got the tank condemned even before I messed up the threads. Now I want to take the tank back to the local shop and tell them what they did but I wonder what retribution I have against them.

Sorry its so long but I am really frustrated about the whole thing and need to know what to do next.

-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: RoboCop
Date Posted: 09 August 2007 at 4:48pm
Looks like you just lost a bunch of money and there is nothing to do about it. Sucks man.


Posted By: StormyKnight
Date Posted: 10 August 2007 at 3:31am
I have two Nitro Duck and two Crossfire tanks.  Both work flawlessly for me.

-------------


Posted By: DRACO
Date Posted: 10 August 2007 at 4:20am

HPA more stable

68c/4500 good overall size will shoot about 1400 rounds before refill.

I run a air hog A5 & X7.

over,



-------------

http://www.southwestregulators.com - REGULATORS
http://a5og.net - A5OG http://x7og.net - X7OG


Posted By: salami
Date Posted: 10 August 2007 at 10:55am

Originally posted by Skillet42565 Skillet42565 wrote:

My tank is currently 3 years out of hydro and no troubles.  NitroDuck pwns.

personally, and dont take this wrongly, but I hope to never ever play within your vicinity sir.... seriously

if your tank ruptures or the reg becomes seperated your not only endangering your self but everyone else, if I dont regularly inspect the brakes on my car and repair replace as needed and I can't stop in time because I ran Junior over playing in the street its no different than me killing junior because my tank just became a missile  or the equiv of a roadside bomb

nuff said, rant off....

back to this gents troubles....

buying used tanks is a great way to get some good HPA stuff for cheap.... as always though its a gamble and sadly you got the band hand this round, ouch, I've found looking for used ones off the paintball forums like the nation and the like or craigslist is the best way, i avoid the bay these days, cool thing about the paintball forums or craigslists you can find people easier that are local to you and that way before any money exchanges hands your able to hold and test the item beforehand, just a hint

whatever you do try and get a working nitro tank, I think once you have found one you will be plesantely surprised at the way it operates overs co2, again good luck

 

 

 



Posted By: +DreX+
Date Posted: 10 August 2007 at 11:22am
yeah, i have a 50/3000 wgp nitro tank, which i picked up for 35$ and it has a year left on the hydro- it shoots just enough to get thru a bag of paint

-------------
Insert Fail Here


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 10 August 2007 at 1:02pm
I finally got my 2nd tank (the crossfire 68/4500) working like it should after 2 rebuilds.  However the first tank (the eBay screw) is still condemned.  I play this weekend at a local Church scenario game so I can test out the working tank I have finally.  I hope and think I will be happy with it.

Thanks for the tip on looking for used stuff on the forums.




-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: mod98commando
Date Posted: 11 August 2007 at 10:03am
Well, good luck at the game Uno, I hope this time it stays working for you. It sucks that you had such bad luck initially but hopefully that's all over now.

-------------
oreomann33: Everybody invades Poland

Rofl_Mao: And everyone eats turkey

Me: But only if they're hungary

Mack: Yeah but hungary people go russian through their food and end up with greece on everyth


Posted By: RoboCop
Date Posted: 11 August 2007 at 10:36am
Now hopefully the reg works and doesn't blow a burst disk.


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 11 August 2007 at 7:23pm
I can finally say I am as happy with my setup and hows it's working as the day I bought the gun and used the first time.

The scenario game was awesome and everything worked very well.

I guess I just needed to vent on the whole thing.

I can't wait to play again.


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: Bruce A. Frank
Date Posted: 11 August 2007 at 10:51pm

Originally posted by uno187 uno187 wrote:

Let me run this by you guys a minute.  Got this tank online due for hydro (my mistake I know now) took it to a local paintball shop for hydro. They called me the next day and said there had been a problem with the tank. They broke the reg off inside the tank. So now its useless. They tell me that whoever had it apart before put too much locktite on it when they put it back together and they couldn't do anything for me on another tank. So I take the tank and broke reg and leave. I proceed to remove the broke half from the bottle messing up the threads a bit. Then I take it to crossfire to see if the can fix it. They can't and condemn the tank for "Exposure to fire and damaged threads". Now I know that the guy who broke the reg in the first place charred the neck and in turn got the tank condemned even before I messed up the threads. Now I want to take the tank back to the local shop and tell them what they did but I wonder what retribution I have against them.

Sorry its so long but I am really frustrated about the whole thing and need to know what to do next.

I would take the tank back to the shop that broke the valve and calmly and clearly state that you took it to Crossfire for evaluation and Crossfire concluded that they, the dealer, used heat on the neck of the tank. Even though you (the owner) successfully removed the broken stub of the valve remaining in the bottle neck, because of the dealer technician's application of so much heat the tank had to be scrapped. You feel they are responsible for the damage to the tank, as trained technicians should know better than to apply excessive heat to the neck of a high pressure cylinder.

The so called excessive use of LocTite should not have stopped a shop with the right tools from removing the valve. Heat was not an option on a high pressure tank. If they could not have removed the valve with their equipment they should have stopped and informed you, not applied heat.

The damage to the threads is less significant than the subjection of the bottle to the excessive heat that Crossfire identified as damage to the tank. If they feel no obligation to compensate you with a new or used tank of equivalent capacity, inform them that you are sorry that you could come to no understanding over their responsibility, but you feel it necessary to inform which ever group sanctioned the training of the technician (a sticker in the window may state where he was trained) of his incompetent and dangerous handling of your HPA tank. Not a threat, just do it.

You have nothing to lose because you certainly will not take your business there again.



-------------


Posted By: mod98commando
Date Posted: 12 August 2007 at 3:03am
Bruce has a point. I recently had my old crossfire tank hydro tested and the same thing happened to me. They tried to remove the reg and the stem broke off inside the tank. I guess I was lucky though, they got it out and there were no signs of heat use at all. I got screwed in the end though because for some reason the new regulator I bought for it will not meet flush with the metal lip of the tank so if I try to fill it, the o-ring gets pushed through the crack and all the air vents out. I've been meaning to grind that so I can use it again but I just haven't had the time.

-------------
oreomann33: Everybody invades Poland

Rofl_Mao: And everyone eats turkey

Me: But only if they're hungary

Mack: Yeah but hungary people go russian through their food and end up with greece on everyth


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 12 August 2007 at 9:14am
You are right about them not getting my business again.  And thanks for tip on finding out who trained this guy. I go to talk to the owner tomorrow and we will see what he will do for me.

Here an FYI when I went to Crossfire with the tank they informed me if they had broke the valve off in the tank they would replace the whole tank for me. Since the are in MI where I live it easy for my to get it there but you could always ship it to the with a few day turn around. 

Crossfire.com check them out they hydro cheap and do reg swaps for a good price too.


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: salami
Date Posted: 12 August 2007 at 9:35am

i always suggest letting the hyrdotester removing the regulator....

now some hydrotesters really dont like doing paintball tanks, some wont treat them with respect and you wait weeks for thier return

check this guy out

http://www.hydrotester.com/ - http://www.hydrotester.com/

top notch company and definately will treat you right, if they bork the tank utilizing thier regulator removal option I doubt they would leave you hanging, if its borked upon arrivial its not thier problem, my advice, let the tester actually do the removal unless your 100 percent positive about your paint shop

 



Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 12 August 2007 at 12:42pm
Yeh I made the mistake of being in a hurry to get the tank done and that particular shop was close.  It won't happen again!

-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit


Posted By: mod98commando
Date Posted: 13 August 2007 at 3:15am
Originally posted by uno187 uno187 wrote:

...
Here an FYI when I went to Crossfire with the tank they informed me if they had broke the valve off in the tank they would replace the whole tank for me. Since the are in MI where I live it easy for my to get it there but you could always ship it to the with a few day turn around. 

Crossfire.com check them out they hydro cheap and do reg swaps for a good price too.


Really? Will they only replace the tank if it was sent to them for hydro testing or if anybody did it? I don't think my tank was sent directly to crossfire so I'm doubtful that they'd be willing to fix somebody else's mistake. I'll probably send my tank to them next time, I'd like to know that my tank will be taken care of. I may drop them an email to see if they can help me out. Thanks for the info though.


-------------
oreomann33: Everybody invades Poland

Rofl_Mao: And everyone eats turkey

Me: But only if they're hungary

Mack: Yeah but hungary people go russian through their food and end up with greece on everyth


Posted By: uno187
Date Posted: 13 August 2007 at 7:33am
If you send it to the for a reg swap and they broke it they would take care of you then too.

Check out their site:

http://www.crossfireinc.com/ - http://www.crossfireinc.com/


-------------
98 Custom Pro
E-grip
cp reg
cp on/off
custom drop
freak barrel kit
Ricochet Apache
68/4500 crossfire
fang trigger
macro line
low pressure kit



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2021 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net