Print Page | Close Window

Dilemma

Printed From: Tippmann Paintball
Category: News And Views
Forum Name: Thoughts and Opinions
Forum Description: Got something you need to say?
URL: http://www.tippmannsports.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=183806
Printed Date: 16 February 2026 at 12:50am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Dilemma
Posted By: Tolgak
Subject: Dilemma
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:30pm
This semester, I got involved in a music group on campus which was created in hopes of growing into a decent sized orchestra. I will refer to the group as an orchestra for the purposes of this thread.

We were invited to play for two Christmas concerts, the first of which has passed.

Turns out, tonight is not a concert, but a mass. Praying, praising Jebus, and all the other rituals that I don't care for. I was told by the man running the affair that it would not be so when I first raised my concern at the first rehearsal for this. So now I have a problem. I've been duped into rehearsing for a ceremony that I  participating in and am receiving no compensation for. I am the lead of 3 trumpet players, and the only one that reliably makes it to performances and rehearsals.

Do I inform the members of the orchestra that I wish no part in the ceremony, and look like an ass for not participating?

or

Do I sit through two hours of drivel and support a cause and an audience that works to oppose people who share my ideals?


-------------



Replies:
Posted By: High Voltage
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:39pm
I'd just suck it up and play the gig. You'll gain experience playing with this group at an event and also have an audience to spread the word about you guys and how well you play. I think you're letting down your friends if you skip it.

-------------


Posted By: FreeEnterprise
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:44pm
You made a commitment. You are only as good as your word.

Nice tolerance btw...

-------------
They tremble at my name...


Posted By: God
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:46pm
Play the concert. Your going there as an invited musical guest, not as a brainwashed participant.


Posted By: scotchyscotch
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:48pm
Originally posted by FreeEnterprise FreeEnterprise wrote:


Nice tolerance btw...


Pot calling the kettle black.


Posted By: jmac3
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:48pm
I would not play it. It isn't something you want to do. 

-------------
Que pasa?




Posted By: jmac3
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:50pm
Originally posted by FreeEnterprise FreeEnterprise wrote:

You made a commitment. You are only as good as your word.

Nice tolerance btw...


Difference between tolerance and not wanting to hang around and listen to mass...


-------------
Que pasa?




Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 1:56pm
Originally posted by FreeEnterprise FreeEnterprise wrote:

You made a commitment. You are only as good as your word.

Nice tolerance btw...


I made a commitment to concerts, not religious affairs. I made it clear in the beginning that I do not wish to play for any sort of rituals, that I wish to play music only for the sake of music and entertainment. Most of the group agrees and has accepted that idea. We were not told that the event would be a mass, we were told it would be a concert. We were lied to, and the news only came out this morning.

As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs. That doesn't mean I can't tolerate those people when they aren't dragging me into those sorts of things.


-------------


Posted By: Evil Elvis
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 2:05pm
show up as an orchestra in some cool Traditional Turkish garb, and see how long it takes them to freak out as all your trumpet cases have clocks and wires attached to them.

-------------


Posted By: High Voltage
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 2:09pm
A gig is a gig, Tolga. Play this one and hopefully you guys will get more in the future. Also, have some good laughs while you're playing the mass.

-------------


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 2:14pm
Originally posted by High Voltage High Voltage wrote:

A gig is a gig, Tolga. Play this one and hopefully you guys will get more in the future. Also, have some good laughs while you're playing the mass.


Yea, the plan has always been to go. I'm just wondering what other people think about it. The people around me share my sentiments, so it could be a good time.


-------------


Posted By: God
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 2:18pm
Improvise a solo as a gift to baby jesus.


Posted By: Gatyr
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 3:27pm
Play the imperial death march when that pastor/priest/holy guy first walks on the stage. 

-------------


Posted By: Frozen Balls
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 3:33pm
Originally posted by Gatyr Gatyr wrote:

Play the imperial death march when that pastor/priest/holy guy first walks on the stage. 


Win.


-------------



Posted By: nickman98
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 3:55pm
so if its agaisnt what you believe in and you were lied to about it how do you even begin to feel like you have to go. this is as clear as it gets to me. dont go and just tell them you dont appreciate being lied to, and good luck.


Posted By: FreeEnterprise
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:12pm
Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs. That doesn't mean I can't tolerate those people when they aren't dragging me into those sorts of things.
 
 
Tolerance
 
1. a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward those whose opinions, practices, race, religion, nationality, etc., differ from one's own; freedom from bigotry.
2. a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward opinions and practices that differ from one's own.
3. interest in and concern for ideas, opinions, practices, etc., foreign to one's own; a liberal, undogmatic viewpoint.
 
Freedom from Bigotry...
 
Hmm, what is bigotry?...
 
1. stubborn and complete intolerance of any creed, belief, or opinion that differs from one's own.
2. the actions, beliefs, prejudices, etc., of a bigot.
 
Good thread, made me laugh.


-------------
They tremble at my name...


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:13pm
Originally posted by nickman98 nickman98 wrote:

so if its agaisnt what you believe in and you were lied to about it how do you even begin to feel like you have to go. this is as clear as it gets to me. dont go and just tell them you dont appreciate being lied to, and good luck.


This was my initial idea, but it wasn't the group that lied to me, it was the people that asked us to come. As a new group on campus, it would look horrible for a player with important parts to abandon a rehearsal. The population of my school is as religious as it gets for non-religious institutions.

To the student population, it wouldn't matter that the organizer lied. I would have skipped out on a church ritual. A Christmas one. That paints me as hellspawn and the group in a very negative light if the organizer decides to get vocal about it (judging by how much of an ass he is at rehearsal, it's very likely).

I can't afford to build a bad reputation for myself on religious grounds when the goal is to be a pilot. The population of the industry is too conservative and religious.

The best I can do is to ensure that we never let this happen again. If we are to be called for a religious ritual, we should be told in advance of the nature of the ritual so that people who don't want to participate can opt out before it is too late.


-------------


Posted By: Yomillio
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:27pm
Dude, if you wanna play, go play and enjoy yourself.  Who cares about the setting, you'll still have a good time playing.

I get that you wouldn't do it had you known about it, and thats fine.  I say just go for it.

I just think this isn't the time to make some sort of stand, nevermind the fact that you'll end up having a good time.


-------------

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=172327 - Forum XBL Gamertag Collection


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:29pm
Originally posted by FreeEnterprise FreeEnterprise wrote:

Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs. That doesn't mean I can't tolerate those people when they aren't dragging me into those sorts of things.
 
 
Tolerance
 
1. a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward those whose opinions, practices, race, religion, nationality, etc., differ from one's own; freedom from bigotry.
3. interest in and concern for ideas, opinions, practices, etc., foreign to one's own; a liberal, undogmatic viewpoint.
 
Freedom from Bigotry...
 
Hmm, what is bigotry?...
 
1. stubborn and complete intolerance of any creed, belief, or opinion that differs from one's own.
2. the actions, beliefs, prejudices, etc., of a bigot.
 
Good thread, made me laugh.


Fair: My belief is certainly fair. I don't believe in the validity of the ritual, so it is fair for me to call it nonsense.
Objective: Not much to say here. I studied Christianity soon after dropping Islam. I was a free soul looking for religion to cling to. I determined that I could not agree with the writings.
Permissive: I'm certainly not advocating for the ritual to be stopped. I just don't want it forced upon me.

I TRY to be ethical. They lied to put me in this position. My commitment to the group is being used to keep me at the ritual.

That 3rd definition doesn't have much of a place here. By that definition, nobody is tolerant nor do they always try to be. You likely have no interest sitting through Friday prayers at a mosque. Definitely not for multiple services. That definition demands that a tolerant person be active and have interest in other ideologies.

You rode BMX. If you had a crew that was hired to provide some entertainment in a parade, and was told the day of the performance that you were working for a gay pride parade, would you still perform? Your history of posts on this forum makes that answer a highly likely "no." Your justifications for not going would firmly place you under the definition of bigot.


-------------


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:32pm
Originally posted by Yomillio Yomillio wrote:

Dude, if you wanna play, go play and enjoy yourself.  Who cares about the setting, you'll still have a good time playing.

I get that you wouldn't do it had you known about it, and thats fine.  I say just go for it.

I just think this isn't the time to make some sort of stand, nevermind the fact that you'll end up having a good time.


Actually, I don't enjoy playing this music. It's boring and simple and not at all challenging (except Hallelujah, I quite like that one). I'll have a good time if I can manage to keep up a conversation with the group around me, but there are no guarantees.

As I said earlier in this thread, I'm going. The only reason is to support the orchestra. That is all.


-------------


Posted By: FreeEnterprise
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:34pm
I don't have a problem with gay's...
 
If I give my word, I keep it.
Do I think a gay lifestyle is wrong, yes, but I do stuff that is wrong too.
 
I've done tons of stuff in my life that I didn't "feel" like doing, because it was good for my career/hobby/experience.
 
You gave your word. Its just two hours...
 
Besides, you might enjoy it.


-------------
They tremble at my name...


Posted By: Ceesman762
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 4:36pm
Tolgak, look at it as a lesson so that you don't get into an "uncomfortable" performance.  Support the orchestra, do it for them.

-------------
Innocence proves nothing
FUAC!!!!!




Posted By: ParielIsBack
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:01pm
Originally posted by FreeEnterprise FreeEnterprise wrote:

I don't have a problem with gay's...
 
If I give my word, I keep it.
Do I think a gay lifestyle is wrong, yes, but I do stuff that is wrong too.
 
I've done tons of stuff in my life that I didn't "feel" like doing, because it was good for my career/hobby/experience.
 
You gave your word. Its just two hours...
 
Besides, you might enjoy it.


Except he gave his word with a specific corollary, that he not have to play at events like these.

I think you should still go, for all the reasons you listed.  But I think you should also make it very clear to the director that you cannot trust them.


-------------
BU Engineering 2012


Posted By: Yomillio
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:05pm
Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

Originally posted by Yomillio Yomillio wrote:

Dude, if you wanna play, go play and enjoy yourself.  Who cares about the setting, you'll still have a good time playing.

I get that you wouldn't do it had you known about it, and thats fine.  I say just go for it.

I just think this isn't the time to make some sort of stand, nevermind the fact that you'll end up having a good time.


Actually, I don't enjoy playing this music. It's boring and simple and not at all challenging (except Hallelujah, I quite like that one). I'll have a good time if I can manage to keep up a conversation with the group around me, but there are no guarantees.

As I said earlier in this thread, I'm going. The only reason is to support the orchestra. That is all.


Thats all the reason you need.

And yeah, oversight on my part for not processing the whole 'church music' thing.


-------------

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=172327 - Forum XBL Gamertag Collection


Posted By: Reb Cpl
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:11pm
Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:



As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs.


Don't you rip on Christians for exactly this?


-------------
?



Posted By: jmac3
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:17pm
FE, you don't have a problem with gay people but think a gay lifestyle is wrong? How does that even begin to make sense in your messed up brain?

-------------
Que pasa?




Posted By: ammolord
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:21pm
Originally posted by jmac3 jmac3 wrote:

FE, you don't have a problem with gay people but think a gay lifestyle is wrong? How does that even begin to make sense in your messed up brain?


-------------
PSN Tag: AmmoLord
XBL: xXAmmoLordXx


~Minister of Tinkering With Things That Go "BOOM!"(AKA Minister of Munitions)~


Posted By: brihard
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:25pm
You promsied attendance base on misrepresentation. You were told it would not be of a religious nature, and were misled. IUt is, and you feel qualms about that.

Yes, you said you would go- but you said you would go based on the information you were given.

Now you have conflicting values. I don't see having given your word coming into play, since that's based on honesty in both directions, and you were lied to. Not your fault. However now you face a conflict of partaking in something that runs contrary to your own beliefs (or lack thereof), and the fact that other people are relying on you and that people will judge you anyway if you don't.

I don't think anyone would have the right to judge you if you chose not to go based on what you've said, but you should go with whatever's most ethically comfortable to you.

I personally would feel no compunction about letting down someone who had lied to me, but I don't think I'd be able to walk out on a bunch of friends like that. I'd do it, then raise hell with whoever lied to me about it. I certainly would not partake in prayer or the like- and I wouldn't be bowing my head, clasping hands or any such thing that might lead people to think I was. If people were uncomfortable with my presence as a result, so be it.

You were recruited to go play music, so play music- but don't let them guilt you into partaking in anything you don't feel comfortable with.

Lesson learned, I guess. Raw deal.


-------------
"Abortion is not "choice" in America. It is forced and the democrats are behind it, with the goal of eugenics at its foundation."

-FreeEnterprise, 21 April 2011.

Yup, he actually said that.


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:45pm
Originally posted by Reb Cpl Reb Cpl wrote:

Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:



As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs.


Don't you rip on Christians for exactly this?


As I've said before, I'll let people believe what they want to believe so long as they do not push their beliefs on other people. I doesn't matter to me if someone wishes ill against a demographic. It begins to matter when that person uses his influence on the lives of others to act on those beliefs.


Bri: my initial preference was to do exactly as you said. But I value my commitment to the orchestra quite well, and have put in a considerable investment in time and money to get playing again. I certainly will take no part in anything other than music.


-------------


Posted By: Eville
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 5:53pm
Being tolerant of something does not require one to be a participant.

-------------


Posted By: brihard
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:11pm
Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

Originally posted by Reb Cpl Reb Cpl wrote:

Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:



As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs.


Don't you rip on Christians for exactly this?


As I've said before, I'll let people believe what they want to believe so long as they do not push their beliefs on other people. I doesn't matter to me if someone wishes ill against a demographic. It begins to matter when that person uses his influence on the lives of others to act on those beliefs.


Bri: my initial preference was to do exactly as you said. But I value my commitment to the orchestra quite well, and have put in a considerable investment in time and money to get playing again. I certainly will take no part in anything other than music.

You might have misread me- my recommendation was to attend out of respect for your peers whoa re relying on you, not out of any sense of commitment to the people who misled you. If nothing else, it's a practice concert.


-------------
"Abortion is not "choice" in America. It is forced and the democrats are behind it, with the goal of eugenics at its foundation."

-FreeEnterprise, 21 April 2011.

Yup, he actually said that.


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:15pm
Originally posted by brihard brihard wrote:

Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

Originally posted by Reb Cpl Reb Cpl wrote:

Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:



As far as tolerance goes, I don't have to tolerate rituals or beliefs.


Don't you rip on Christians for exactly this?


As I've said before, I'll let people believe what they want to believe so long as they do not push their beliefs on other people. I doesn't matter to me if someone wishes ill against a demographic. It begins to matter when that person uses his influence on the lives of others to act on those beliefs.


Bri: my initial preference was to do exactly as you said. But I value my commitment to the orchestra quite well, and have put in a considerable investment in time and money to get playing again. I certainly will take no part in anything other than music.

You might have misread me- my recommendation was to attend out of respect for your peers whoa re relying on you, not out of any sense of commitment to the people who misled you. If nothing else, it's a practice concert.


And you may have misread me, because I just said exactly the same thing.

Damn the internet and its reduction in communication efficiency.


-------------


Posted By: brihard
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:17pm
Sorry- the way you said 'but I value my music' led me to think that you interpreted my reccommendation as not to go.

On another note, Who's on first?


-------------
"Abortion is not "choice" in America. It is forced and the democrats are behind it, with the goal of eugenics at its foundation."

-FreeEnterprise, 21 April 2011.

Yup, he actually said that.


Posted By: Gator Taco
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:18pm
Originally posted by High Voltage High Voltage wrote:

A gig is a gig, Tolga. Play this one and hopefully you guys will get more in the future. Also, have some good laughs while you're playing the mass.

Agreed.

Have a chuckle at their mass and play the gig. You'll be glad you did. It's only two hours.


-------------
http://www.last.fm/user/trailgator01 - last.fm


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:25pm
Originally posted by brihard brihard wrote:

Sorry- the way you said 'but I value my music' led me to think that you interpreted my reccommendation as not to go.

On another note, Who's on first?


The fat bastard that lied to us with an opening prayer.

We play throughout the entire thing, including the closing bit.


-------------


Posted By: Yomillio
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 6:37pm
Originally posted by ammolord ammolord wrote:

Originally posted by jmac3 jmac3 wrote:

FE, you don't have a problem with gay people but think a gay lifestyle is wrong? How does that even begin to make sense in your messed up brain?


I would assume FE thinks along the line that he doesn't want to infringe on other's rights or make a poor opinion of someone, although he does believe it is wrong.

Pretty similar on my thoughts on abortion - my moral standards say it is wrong unless rape or similar is involved (and adoption is of course an option for this anyways - trying to steer this away from an abortion argument), but I still believe the decision itself should be left up to one's own moral standards.

Just because one thinks something is wrong, doesn't mean that they have to take issue with it in every instance, especially with something like homosexuality.


-------------

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/forum_posts.asp?TID=172327 - Forum XBL Gamertag Collection


Posted By: Reb Cpl
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 7:07pm
Originally posted by brihard brihard wrote:


On another note, Who's on first?


Naturally.


-------------
?



Posted By: Darur
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 7:59pm
Just treat it as a learning experience.

I've been to plenty of religious ceremonies, from Catholic to Buddhist to Mormon to Pagan, which have nothing to do with my beliefs, many of which I disagreed with personally, but I went and I was respectful and open-minded because there were people there who truly believed in what was being practiced.  No one's going to be forcing you to accept Jesus, or rounding up heathens to burn.

Tolerance isn't just for the people being tolerated, its for the person who is doing the tolerating.  If you let yourself get so worked up and hurt over people worshiping in a way you disagree, you're only hurting yourself.


-------------
Real Men play Tuba

[IMG]http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/1859/newsmall6xz.jpg">

PH33R TEH 1337 Dwarf!

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/log_off_user.asp" rel="nofollow - DONT CLICK ME!!1


Posted By: nickman98
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 8:08pm
Originally posted by Darur Darur wrote:

Just treat it as a learning experience.

I've been to plenty of religious ceremonies, from Catholic to Buddhist to Mormon to Pagan, which have nothing to do with my beliefs, many of which I disagreed with personally, but I went and I was respectful and open-minded because there were people there who truly believed in what was being practiced.  No one's going to be forcing you to accept Jesus, or rounding up heathens to burn.

Tolerance isn't just for the people being tolerated, its for the person who is doing the tolerating.  If you let yourself get so worked up and hurt over people worshiping in a way you disagree, you're only hurting yourself.
just tell that to the natives or any other groups of people who have been rounded up by people who have different belifes and greater power to exercise them. hope the concert dosnt kill ya Wink


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 9:07pm
It's over. It bored the hell out of me and lost me an opportunity for a good night.

Did I learn anything? Yea, bring entertainment next time.

Originally posted by Darur Darur wrote:

Tolerance isn't just for the people being tolerated, its for the person who is doing the tolerating.  If you let yourself get so worked up and hurt over people worshiping in a way you disagree, you're only hurting yourself.


Again, my issue is that I was given an acceptable expectation for the performance, and it turned out to be a ritual I wished no involvement in. I was forced into it under false pretenses. I've stated it plenty of times and will say so again, I don't care who or what people worship, I don't want to be forced to listen to or support their rituals. Today I was forced to do both.

Anyway. The issue is now resolved, and a few of us in the orchestra made it clear to the founder that he should screen suspect performances and tell us the reason behind them before asking for our commitment.


-------------


Posted By: Rofl_Mao
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 9:44pm
Love how you guys say "ritual" like its some sort of animal sacrifice for something. lul.


Posted By: Koolit32
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 9:48pm
Hardcore non-believers don't play in orchestras.
/thread


Posted By: choopie911
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 10:09pm
A gig is a gig man, would you not play at a jewish wedding or something? Yeah you have to listen to them drivel about jesus for hours, but your role isn't any different, and it's hardly the worst thing you could have to listen to while you wait.

I say play it, and I'm a firm athiest, a gig is a gig.


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 10:13pm
Originally posted by choopie911 choopie911 wrote:

A gig is a gig man, would you not play at a jewish wedding or something? Yeah you have to listen to them drivel about jesus for hours, but your role isn't any different, and it's hardly the worst thing you could have to listen to while you wait.

I say play it, and I'm a firm athiest, a gig is a gig.


See above posts.


-------------


Posted By: Darur
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 10:35pm
Out of curiosity, would you play at Mardi Gras?

-------------
Real Men play Tuba

[IMG]http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/1859/newsmall6xz.jpg">

PH33R TEH 1337 Dwarf!

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/log_off_user.asp" rel="nofollow - DONT CLICK ME!!1


Posted By: mbro
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 10:58pm
Originally posted by Rofl_Mao Rofl_Mao wrote:

Love how you guys say "ritual" like its some sort of animal sacrifice for something. lul.
What is the difference?

-------------

Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.


Posted By: Rofl_Mao
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:11pm
They dont?


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:42pm
Originally posted by Darur Darur wrote:

Out of curiosity, would you play at Mardi Gras?


I didn't get paid for tonight, and tonight was a straight up ritual. I joined to play music for the sake of playing music with no other reasons attached. This is a school club.

I'll play for religious groups and whatever if I have incentive to be there. I've been paid for a religious gig before, it's no big deal to me. But I have no desire to volunteer for it, and it's especially bad that they lied to me to get me into the situation. If I support a group I don't care for, they'd better be supporting me. That's the way I work.


-------------


Posted By: __sneaky__
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:49pm
I probably would not have played the gig. Not because I am anti-christian (altho I'm not a huge fan of religion) but I just think, if they are there to worship their god, let them do so. If you really did not want to be there, you should not have gone. Music is about enjoying what you are doing, if you have 0 interest in their rituals and you are not going to enjoy yourself, don't go.

-------------
"I AM a crossdresser." -Reb Cpl


Forum Vice President

RIP T&O Forum


Posted By: God
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:52pm
I changed my mind, dont go and dont play.


Posted By: Shub
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:52pm
You didn't make a commitment to playing the church service. You made a commitment to the band. The band made the commitment to the service. Especially in a large band setting, you aren't going to have the entire musical group of like mind 100% of the time. And you're gonna play gigs that you didn't want to play.


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 03 December 2009 at 11:56pm
Originally posted by Shub Shub wrote:

You didn't make a commitment to playing the church service. You made a commitment to the band. The band made the commitment to the service. Especially in a large band setting, you aren't going to have the entire musical group of like mind 100% of the time. And you're gonna play gigs that you didn't want to play.


Our bylaws don't require us to go to any performances. We're in it for fun, to require participation is against everyone's beliefs.

It is a school club, btw. Not something we do for compensation.


-------------


Posted By: Koolit32
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 12:13am
That wierd feeling you get  from playing during the rituals is JESUS TALKING TO YOU.




Posted By: mbro
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 10:11pm
Originally posted by Rofl_Mao Rofl_Mao wrote:

They dont?
"Theologically speaking, the world has been going downhill ever since man first offered entrails to the gods"



*Name the quote



What makes your ritual worship better or different than another religion that offers animals as part of its worship?

-------------

Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.


Posted By: Rofl_Mao
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 10:15pm
We don't kill animals.


Posted By: The Guy
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 10:28pm
put games on your phone.

-------------
http://www.anomationanodizing.com - My Site


Posted By: __sneaky__
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 10:28pm
Originally posted by Rofl_Mao Rofl_Mao wrote:

We don't kill animals.
Your god is'nt worthy of killing animals?
(I already know why christians don't do animal sacrifice, I just like playing devil's advocate)

-------------
"I AM a crossdresser." -Reb Cpl


Forum Vice President

RIP T&O Forum


Posted By: impulse!!
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 10:58pm
I would bail

-------------


Posted By: mbro
Date Posted: 04 December 2009 at 11:00pm
Originally posted by Rofl_Mao Rofl_Mao wrote:

We don't kill animals.
Why is that better than what their god desires?

-------------

Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.


Posted By: Reb Cpl
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 6:04am
Oh good, this has turned into another "Christians are Dumb" thread. I was wondering how long it would take. 

-------------
?



Posted By: Tical3.0
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 7:09am
Originally posted by Reb Cpl Reb Cpl wrote:

Oh good, this has turned into another "Christians are Dumb" thread. I was wondering how long it would take. 
3 pages down. Figured it would have happend sooner.

-------------
I ♣ hippies.


Posted By: oldsoldier
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 10:19am
First off you are part of a group that committed to provide a set of music for the event. On that alone it is case closed, if every member of the group could pick and choose where and when they were present to play there is no group.

Second, you listen and learn and understand Sun Tzu's addage of "know thy enemy", you will have a better understanding of what now you only have as perception of.

I have played with son's band at various gigs that I personally do not approve of, but I committed to the band not the venue. Playing for 6 total hours (3 sets) at a gay bar was a interesting gig, son and band see it as only '$' and did not judge, as I did. Also played music that I am not a fan of, but again good of the group.

If you back out, that will show the depth of your charactor is as shallow as your belief system. Yes bigotted.

-------------


Posted By: slackerr26
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 10:21am
um he already did it? your a little late

-------------


Posted By: Eville
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 12:37pm
Originally posted by oldsoldier oldsoldier wrote:

First off you are part of a group that committed to provide a set of music for the event. On that alone it is case closed, if every member of the group could pick and choose where and when they were present to play there is no group.



He and his group agreed to play for an even that was not supposed to be a religious service.  They did not agree to play for an event that was a religious service.  The event they agreed to to and the event they went to were two different events, so he was not obligated to go.  The group and the church had a deal, the church changed their end, the group is no longer committed to it. 

That being said, I think that refusing to play music for a group based on their religion would have been childish and would only have served to deny the group a chance to practice together in front of an audience. 


-------------


Posted By: Rofl_Mao
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 1:13pm
Originally posted by mbro mbro wrote:

Originally posted by Rofl_Mao Rofl_Mao wrote:

We don't kill animals.
Why is that better than what their god desires?


Who's god?


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 1:15pm
Originally posted by Eville Eville wrote:

Originally posted by oldsoldier oldsoldier wrote:

First off you are part of a group that committed to provide a set of music for the event. On that alone it is case closed, if every member of the group could pick and choose where and when they were present to play there is no group.



He and his group agreed to play for an even that was not supposed to be a religious service.  They did not agree to play for an event that was a religious service.  The event they agreed to to and the event they went to were two different events, so he was not obligated to go.  The group and the church had a deal, the church changed their end, the group is no longer committed to it. 

That being said, I think that refusing to play music for a group based on their religion would have been childish and would only have served to deny the group a chance to practice together in front of an audience. 


The religion issue is significant because it's the justification for many people that were in attendance to say hateful things toward the non religious. I didn't just support a religious ritual, I supported people who have said to my face and through other interactions that I am evil/don't belong/etc. I knew they would be there. Is it bigoted of me to be opposed to serving these people?


-------------


Posted By: Eville
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 1:28pm
No, but it would be a good opportunity to show them up and possibly ruin the service for them.

-------------


Posted By: ParielIsBack
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 5:12pm
Or kick them in the face.

Coming from someone who is religious, both sides of the argument are stupid.  The problem, from my point of view, is not that you had to go to a religious service (although it may be in your's, Tolgak) but that the director lied to you.  Once he's broken his word, there's no reason for you to do things you dislike.

Originally posted by oldsoldier oldsoldier wrote:

First off you are part of a group that committed to provide a set of music for the event. On that alone it is case closed, if every member of the group could pick and choose where and when they were present to play there is no group.

Second, you listen and learn and understand Sun Tzu's addage of "know thy enemy", you will have a better understanding of what now you only have as perception of.

I have played with son's band at various gigs that I personally do not approve of, but I committed to the band not the venue. Playing for 6 total hours (3 sets) at a gay bar was a interesting gig, son and band see it as only '$' and did not judge, as I did. Also played music that I am not a fan of, but again good of the group.

If you back out, that will show the depth of your charactor is as shallow as your belief system. Yes bigotted.


Bull poop.

No one's required to interact with people who aren't treating them fairly, and not attending a church service because you made clear you don't want to is absolutely reasonable.

If he had chosen to do anything the group wanted, and not made clear his intentions, it would be a different story.  But he did, so your line of reasoning doesn't make sense.


-------------
BU Engineering 2012


Posted By: Darur
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 5:47pm
Originally posted by Tolgak Tolgak wrote:

 
The religion issue is significant because it's the justification for many people that were in attendance to say hateful things toward the non religious. I didn't just support a religious ritual, I supported people who have said to my face and through other interactions that I am evil/don't belong/etc. I knew they would be there. Is it bigoted of me to be opposed to serving these people?

/facepalm

You do realize that this butthurt mentality of "they all are saying mean things about me!" is common to both Atheists and Religious individuals?  That there are some Christians who would refuse to support some group they associated with Atheism because they think these people are all saying mean things about them?  You do see how silly and childish both sides are here, right?  Because the majority of Religious and Atheist people don't actually spend most of their time planning the Final Solution to the other group?

I've had some strict Christian friends tell me that atheists attack and mock their beliefs, so they don't like atheists.  I've had some atheist friends tell me that Christians attack and mock their lack of belief, so they don't like Christians.  The majority of Christians and Atheists don't give a good God damn what the other side believes in, or doesn't believe in, and very few would judge.   Sure there are some nuts on both sides who DO care, but they don't actually speak for all people with similar views.  


-------------
Real Men play Tuba

[IMG]http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/1859/newsmall6xz.jpg">

PH33R TEH 1337 Dwarf!

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/log_off_user.asp" rel="nofollow - DONT CLICK ME!!1


Posted By: ParielIsBack
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 6:55pm
So he should show up to their services even though their morals are clearly wrong, because there are actually decent people out there?

I think not.  If he feels that their community has treated him unfairly, it's more than reasonable for him not to participate.

That said, I agree that he shouldn't judge a group based on the actions of a few members.


-------------
BU Engineering 2012


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 05 December 2009 at 8:35pm
Originally posted by ParielIsBack ParielIsBack wrote:

So he should show up to their services even though their morals are clearly wrong, because there are actually decent people out there?

I think not.  If he feels that their community has treated him unfairly, it's more than reasonable for him not to participate.

That said, I agree that he shouldn't judge a group based on the actions of a few members.


Thank you. That was the point I was trying to make.

To put the situation more clearly.

Background:
1) The orchestra is a school club. It's not a paid organization. It has no obligations to any organizations until a venue is agreed upon.
2) I set my terms of participation in the group and they were accepted by the group and adopted by a few other members. The people that request us are informed of the nature of this agreement.
3) I set my terms of participation in the "concert," which were accepted by the group.
4) The group was lied to, even though I made an effort to learn what type of performance it would be.
5) We found out the nature of the performance the morning of.
6) The service was run by a few people who take their beliefs far enough that I clearly wouldn't be welcome there had any of them found out what mine were.
7) People who know of who I am and have similar beliefs as those in point #4 were in attendance.
8) The ritual is part of a belief system that has been highly influential in the development of their opinions.
9) I'm the lead Trumpet of the orchestra, and the other trumpets would not have the time to prepare to cover my part on such short notice.
10) The orchestra is new and its reputation could have been significantly affected by the performance.
11) The majority of people in this school would have had similar responses to FE, oldsoldier, Darur, etc (no understanding of my perspective). Raising a big stink over the issue would raise enough hell to affect my future (the aviation industry is super conservative).

Action: I chose to perform.

Results:
1) Music performed as planned.
2) Members with beliefs similar to mine also voice objections to performance.
3) Policy modified.
4) Insult toward non-believers expressed in comments before closing prayer by one of the event organizers.
5) Plans for night ruined (event was promised to be less than 1/2 the length we were initially told).

So I lost some dignity that night. That's something I believe is worth fighting for. I'm not letting this happen to me again.


-------------


Posted By: Darur
Date Posted: 06 December 2009 at 12:52am
Originally posted by ParielIsBack ParielIsBack wrote:

So he should show up to their services even though their morals are clearly wrong, because there are actually decent people out there?

I skipped the rest after that sentence

Tolga -
Actually, the "stink" I'm raising has nothing at all to do with you performing or not. That's entirely your choice, and given the circumstances I wouldn't blame you for not wanting to perform.  The manager lied and you found yourself doing something you weren't comfortable with for no pay. Kudos to you for sucking it up and doing it anyway, not backing out on the rest of your group.

What I don't like is the fact that you seem to have lumped together all religious folk as a party of intolerant, ignorant, and mean-spirited individuals .  Perhaps this group was just that, but from the details you gave it sounded like you were upset because you had to go perform for some group of religious people and you weren't alright with it because all religious people are out to get you.  That struck me as very ignorant on your part.


-------------
Real Men play Tuba

[IMG]http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/1859/newsmall6xz.jpg">

PH33R TEH 1337 Dwarf!

http://www.tippmann.com/forum/wwf77a/log_off_user.asp" rel="nofollow - DONT CLICK ME!!1


Posted By: Tolgak
Date Posted: 06 December 2009 at 10:19am
Originally posted by Darur Darur wrote:

What I don't like is the fact that you seem to have lumped together all religious folk as a party of intolerant, ignorant, and mean-spirited individuals .  Perhaps this group was just that, but from the details you gave it sounded like you were upset because you had to go perform for some group of religious people and you weren't alright with it because all religious people are out to get you.  That struck me as very ignorant on your part.


I keep trying to say this about my beliefs and my school.

1) I don't care to support religious rituals no matter how involved of a ritual it is. It doesn't matter to me if it's a pre-meal prayer or a full reinactment of the crucifixion. I want nothing to do with them, and will not participate in them or support them unless I get something out of it.

Why? I'm not religious and I don't believe in any of it. I don't see it right to lie by pretending I have any meaningful involvement in what they do. I will usually stand aside and let the group do its thing. If they ask me to be involved, I make it breif that I do not want to and I back out. When people begin to oblige me, that's when I start getting defensive.

The only grouping I'm doing is religious vs. non. I have said in this thread that I oppose the ritual because it's part of a belief system that does bring out the nasty side of many people. That's correct. I don't like Christianity or any other religion for that matter. But I haven't pointed out the entire group.

2) My school is composed of super-conservative people. Except for about 5 people, most people who I've had a conversation about religion with have professed not only very strong religious views, but political ones as well. Many of these people see fit to judge you on those views. I've sat through class periods where a mention of politics or climate sparked an explosion of people yelling about the topic, trying to make the professor agree with their views.

We have a class called University 101, which you take your first semester. It's a once a week deal where the professor explains college life and teaches students what they should be careful for and how to adapt to the change in culture. The teacher had a lesson on religious diversity, and a few kids went on a rant about Jesus being the savior and how those who don't believe are sinners and so on and so forth. I've heard the same people and others go on like that in other classes before. The people from that class also appeared that night.

A more recent example. The professor I had for Climatology is a well renowned scientist who had to explain to a student why the scientific community uses BCE and CE instead of BC and AD (it appeared in a chart he showed us). The class essentially went *KABOOM!!!* The same happened on a mention of Islam in a humanities class and the mention of politics in Flight Safety and climate change in any of my meteorology classes. Even some of my professors bring up these topics when they have no relevance to what we're learning.

So if I grouped all of you under one umbrella, I'm sorry. I don't believe that all religious folk are the same. The demographics of my school include a high percentage of very religious and very political people. I know many such people and I know what they believe and express about people unlike them. I knew they would be there that night and it was true that they were.


-------------



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2021 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net